About this case
The facts of this case originate from serious mismanagement at the Emalahleni Local Municipality (Witbank) and the Thaba Chweu Local Municipality (Lydenburg), as well as the inability of the National Treasury to intervene. The bankrupt municipalities could not meet their debtor obligations towards Eskom, and Eskom decided to terminate the electricity supply to the municipalities. If Eskom were allowed to continue unabated, it would pave the way for paying end-users to suffer nationwide damage due to state decay and disputes between state organs. Sakeliga joined as an amicus curiae (friend of the court) and over the course of two years developed legal arguments that the High Court in Pretoria described as "novel" and "decisive." The foremost of these arguments include provisions on intergovernmental dispute resolution; the necessity of rational debt collection methods; and the status of businesses and the public as the real end-users of electricity, rather than the municipalities as Eskom had claimed. • The judgment provides electricity security at the local level, as it prevents Eskom from cutting off end-users' power as a tactic to recover municipal debt. • The judgment reduces the impact of state decay, as it obligates all state institutions – not just Eskom and municipalities – to follow intergovernmental dispute resolution rather than harming paying private third parties.
Case Documents
Resilient Eskom's filing sheet record of decision Rule 53
PDFBinder1 Neils affidavit Coetzee and Resilient 16 April 2018
PDFBinder1 Resilient Urgent app 12 Dec 2017 to page 280
PDFReplying Affidavit of applicant Resilient
PDFIndex to Applicant Resilient replying affidavit
PDFR573 Applicants Supplementary Affidavit
PDFeMalahleni answering affidavit
PDFCourt order 12 December 2017
PDFAnnexure RA7 to Resilient RA
PDFAnnexure RA8 to Resilient RA
PDFAnnexure RA2 to Resilient RA
PDFAnnexure RA4 to Resilient RA
PDFAnnexure RA5 to Resilient RA
PDFAnnexure RA6 to Resilient RA
PDF1st Respondent Eskom answering affidavit
PDFAnnexure ES5 to Eskom AA
PDFAnnexure ES6 to Eskom AA
PDFAnnexure ES7 to Eskom AA
PDFAnnexure RA1 to Resilient RA
PDFAnnexure RA3 to Resilent RA
PDFAnnexure ES1 to Eskom AA
PDFAnnexure ES3 to Eskom AA
PDFAnnexure ES4 to Eskom AA
PDFAnnexure ES2 to Eskom AA
PDF2020-12-29 Judgment, SCA
PDF2019-03-07 Judgment, High Court
PDFOrder, Constitutional Court
PDF2021-09-23 Order, Constitutional Court in re Sabie
PDF