Sakeliga Approaches ConCourt to Protect Legal Recourse Against Unlawful Municipal Conduct
If permitted to stand, the SCA judgment would allow municipalities to disregard or contravene their own land-use regulations.
Sakeliga has sought admission as amicus curiae (friend of the court) in a Constitutional Court matter to protect the public’s legal recourse against illegal settlements and comparable instances when municipalities and other state entities act unlawfully or fail to enforce the law.
The case involves the Polokwane Local Municipality’s decision to relocate occupiers onto municipal agricultural land, where it subsequently permitted unauthorised land use and illegal structures. Despite finding that the Polokwane Local Municipality had contravened its own town planning scheme and by-law, as well as national building and environmental legislation, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) nevertheless declined to grant an interdict when a farm owner of adjacent agricultural land approached it for relief.
According to the SCA judgment, a contravention of legislation by an organ of state “does not in itself” entitle an applicant to interdictory legal relief. The SCA held that the applicant must also prove that it has suffered individual harm, in addition to the harm suffered by the public in general. The SCA found individual harm was not established.
If permitted to stand, the SCA judgment would allow municipalities – unlike law-abiding businesses and other residents who are frequently confronted with strict building and development by-laws and other legislation – to disregard or contravene their own land-use regulations. It would also allow municipalities to dismiss warranted grievances simply because an affected party cannot demonstrate direct harm, even though property owners, developers, businesses, and residents rely on municipalities to apply and enforce planning, building, and environmental laws lawfully and consistently. In effect, the SCA judgment would render compliance with the law by organs of state discretionary, and its judicial enforcement arbitrary, at a time when municipal mismanagement and decay in South Africa is already extensive.
Given the far-reaching implications for property rights and the rule of law, Sakeliga now seeks to join as amicus curiae in the recently filed application for leave to appeal. We intend to assist the Constitutional Court by advancing submissions against the SCA’s finding, including that:
- Organs of state are subject to a different standard than private persons.
The SCA applied a test developed for disputes between private persons, in which a court asks how the complainant itself has been harmed. That question is appropriate between private persons, who have no duty to enforce the law against one another. An organ of state is in a different position and may do only what the law allows and must do what the law requires. It owes these duties to everyone within its jurisdiction. Its conduct should therefore be measured by its lawfulness. - Unlawful conduct by an organ of state is itself the injury.
Where an organ of state fails to comply with the law or to perform a statutory duty, that failure is the injury, and a court should be able to correct it without proof of special or financial harm to the applicant. - Parties have a right to litigate in the public interest.
Section 38(d) of the Constitution entitles anyone acting in the public interest to approach a court, without having suffered harm themselves. A requirement of individual harm to the applicant cannot be reconciled with this provision. The SCA’s finding would preclude public-interest interdicts against organs of state, however plain the unlawfulness.
Apart from these constitutional considerations, the SCA’s judgment flies in the face of one of its own earlier judgments, wherein the SCA held in 2013 that owners and occupiers in an area covered by a town planning scheme may enforce that scheme without proving that they have suffered special damage. After the latest SCA finding, the High Courts are now faced with two contradictory SCA judgments, a defect which in itself warrants correction by the Constitutional Court.
Context
The matter concerns two adjoining portions of agricultural land owned by the Polokwane Local Municipality and a commercial farmer, respectively (see judgment under “Resources” below).
The Municipality relocated land occupiers onto its portion by council resolution and permitted the erection of illegal structures without approved plans or certificates of occupancy. In response to a complaint lodged by the farmers under the Municipality’s land use scheme, the Municipality merely confirmed the council resolution and took no steps to investigate or to enforce its own by-law.
The owners of the adjoining land applied to the Limpopo High Court for interdicts and for an order compelling the Municipality and the provincial MEC for Agriculture and Rural Development to enforce the law. The High Court dismissed the application in August 2024.
On 2 October 2026, the SCA dismissed the application for leave to appeal. It did so while maintaining that the applicants have established "beyond question" their clear right to demand that municipal land be used lawfully and that the relevant legislation be enforced. Furthermore, the court recognised that the Municipality's failure to act deprived the applicants of any effective alternative remedy. The applicants have since applied to the Constitutional Court for leave to appeal.
Why Sakeliga seeks admission
Businesses and communities ultimately bear the cost when municipalities disregard the law, and legal recourse is frequently the last available remedy. Left to stand, the SCA’s now contradictory finding would weaken that recourse for property owners, businesses, and communities, well beyond the parties to this case. Sakeliga seeks to place these broader, public-interest legal implications, which the parties have not raised, before the Constitutional Court.
We have applied for admission at the leave to appeal stage, so that these submissions can assist the Constitutional Court when it decides whether to hear the appeal.
Resources
Help us secure a flourishing economy
You can restore economic order by funding our work.
