About this case
State procurement regulations made in 2017 by the Minister of Finance represented a watershed moment in procurement and BEE in South Africa. Before 2017, companies tendering for state contracts could be penalised at most by 10% to 20% if they did not meet BEE requirements. This was damaging enough. Since the 2017 regulations, however, organs of state have gone much further: tender requirements began to outright exclude companies based on BEE criteria, for example, if a company was not 100% black-owned. After a legal battle of 5 years, Sakeliga was able to have the minister's 2017 regulations declared invalid and unconstitutional, with the final order in the Constitutional Court. The victory is the first comprehensive rollback of BEE through litigation. The Constitutional Court found in favor of Sakeliga on February 16, 2022, that the Minister of Finance at the time, Pravin Gordhan, acted ultra vires (beyond powers) by regulating as though he had legislative authority. This victory follows Sakeliga's earlier success in the matter before the Supreme Court of Appeal. • The court case is one of the most influential on state affairs in the last three decades. • The independence of state organs to determine their own procurement policies – with or without BEE and other political considerations – and to undertake value-for-money procurement has been restored. • The judgment has caused procurement practitioners at all levels to rethink state procurement and to focus on value for money. • The momentum of the government to strengthen BEE and other political requirements in state procurement has been broken.
Case Documents
High Court Papers NOM and FA Case no 34523-17 Sakeliga (previously Afribusiness NPC) v Minister of Finance
PDFSakeliga (previously Afribusiness) NOM and FA 2017 Pretoria High Court
PDFHigh Court Papers Bundle - pages 734 - 822
PDFHigh Court Papers Bundle pages 609 - 733
PDFHigh Court Bundle pages 508 - 608
PDFHigh Court Papers Bundle - pages 306 - 406
PDFHigh Court Papers Court Bundle - pages 205 - 305
PDFHigh Court Papers Bundle pages 108 - 204
PDF2017 Court Papers - High Court Bundle pages 1 - 107
PDF2019-08-28 Replying affidavit
PDFApplication for leave to appeal
PDF2019-10-01 Notice of appeal
PDFAfribusiness (Sakeliga) v Minister of Finance FA
PDFAfribusiness (Sakeliga) v Minister of Finance NOM
PDF2021-04-26 Respondents heads of argument
PDFAFRIBUSINESS NPC v The Minister of Finance.Appellants HOA
PDFMinister of Finance Fidelity Amicus Bundel Vol 1
PDFMinister of Finance Fidelity Amicus Bundel Vol 2
PDFMinister of Finance Fidelity Amicus Bundel Vol 4
PDFMinister of Finance Fidelity Amicus Bundel Vol 3
PDFMinister of Finance Fidelity Amicus Bundel Vol 5
PDF
